I rate them all pretty highly. They all do good things for my face and as I often shave at night I enjoy the fact that the scent doesn't last too long.
My order would be:
I also seem to be the only one on the planet who didn't get on with their Emulsion. I may have to revisit it.
- Plastic Shave - great face feel.
- Aqua Balsamica - works well with many of my favourite soaps (MdC, LPL, Stirling Ozark Mountain)
- Formula C
- Formal K - bracing peppermint
- Aqua di Limon - I quite like the scent, sweet lemon. It works well with B&M Cheshire.
- Antesol - a bit meh for me.
I won't touch Emulsion due to its controversial preservative.