Many thanks for your trusting words - but I really don't see myself as an expert, just somebody who likes (most) of their products. So I only do essential oils - can't say anything about their fragrance oil line...My favourites scent wise are bay rum (very different to mikes - much sweeter scent, although I also love mikes) & bergamot & lavender. I also like Bonaparte, but my wife doesn't and don't mind lavender & sage, although the scent is a bit week on that one. I think you can easily compare the performance of the lather to Mikes, but it is way easier and faster to get there. Post shave wise I would also say the 2 are very similar - which one is better? Well always the one I have just used
I am just trying a sample of the electric sheep one - great performance, but surprisingly lags in the post shave feel. Not bad but definitely not as fantastic.
I also very much enjoy their alcohol witch hazel BTW