Agreed. But in this case the question was merely "does it smell like Hubba Bubba"; or words to that effect.There is nothing to nail, it's fragrance oil.
It obviously wasn't a big ask given the fragrance oil does all the work. But, it at least delivers what is on the tin.
Out of curiosity: Given how artificial the classic Hubba Bubba scent was, would it be possible/practical to recreate it with essential oils?