Admin Post Yep, get both. Very different in taste.... the Laphroaig is going to smack you with the mecidinal/antiseptic notes of smoldering peat, while the Highland Park is a cleaner 'bonfire' peat. Had a Signatory Unchill filtered collection dram last week - 24yo Glen Rothes: https://www.signatoryusa.com/scotch/glen-rothes-1999/ Great stuff. Very, very enjoyable. Also a Cadenheads bottling of something, will need to check the receipt... but the Rothes was so good I forgot all about it!