Shower
Merkur 1904
Personna Lab Blue (4)
Omega 48
GFT Rose Cream
Nivea ASB
CK Obsession
For me and Omega piggies, bigger is better. The Omega banded boars are much more broken in from the get go - the standard ones take ages by comparison (although the firmer feel is not a bad thing). The banding treatment does something to the bristle. If I was going again my choice in big boars would be the 20248 brush. But if you want an economical way to make and apply lather, a synth can't be beaten. But at least boars don't hog it like badgers (see what I did there?!). The boars give you a higher loft with more backbone and when the split tips get "wispy" after properly breaking in (yes it can take a long time), the face feel is very nice. My big boars are also a nice way to chew through the decades of soap I have in stock so I can start buying some more! Some soaps are better suited to boars though - particularly high structure versions.
The tub of dried out cream I used today (loaded like a puck as a result) is a much better fit with synth / badger though - I keep trying with the big boars but it just doesn't work as well. The surface of the tub is actually quite sticky, so I have noticed a few bristles getting pulled out of the boars as well, which is annoying and not something one had to deal with in synths and only rarely in badgers. So I find there are different soaps / creams that best suit different brushes, just like I find some blades that are horrible in my favourite razors, become excellent in razors that never usually work for me (as per today's combo). But if economy of soap is the goal, synths are the only game in town!
awesome reply mate.. i had never even considered the concept of different types of brushes for different soaps before.
when you say they are better in a high structure soap, do you mean like a soap like tabac?
One more question on breaking in the brush, how many uses do you think it takes? i have an Omega 11137 which does not seem banded (i cant see any banding and its listed as a Pure Bristle). I reckon i have used it around 25-30 times so far..
BTW my goal is not just about economy, that is just something i noted while using. I recently bought a badger (silvertip) and this boar for a different experience while lathering.
The badger gives a very luxurious feel while lathering but hogs quite a lot of lather.
The boar is more scritchy and only produces a decent lather for first pass while leaving substituent passes quite thin causing me to add more soap at this point.
Synthetics have both the soft luxurious feel, produce lots of lather quite easily and dont hog.
I am hoping my boar isnt broken in yet and i have more to look forward to. But will also be trying it with different soaps to see.