Trumpers Lime Skinfood
Thater 4125/1
Tims Signature
ATT S2
Lord Cool (2)
Hai Karate AS
Last edited by a moderator:
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Brush: Chubby 2 Manchurian
Razor: Wolfman
Blade: Scottish Perma sharp
Soap: Wickhams 1912 Russian Leather
A/S: Real Shaving Balm
Cologne: Paco Rabanne
Really starting to enjoy this razor now that I've used it a few times and have figured out the ideal angle. It's certainly not a mild razor but once dialled in is very quick and easy to use.
LPL soap performance is great this is there first tallow soap, scent is a mild cologne doesn't last long great performance, LPL soap is my favorite soap at the moment.Great looing shave Cranky.
How does the soap smell and preform?
So what does this smell like? Well like most of Douglas' productions it is really hard to tell. There is so much going on and it is so well layered that it is hard to tell where one note stops and the next begins. The soap itself appears to be a evolution of his genre-breaking 'Dirt' scent, but this one smells very earthy, kind of dusty in comparison. This is driven by strong Vetiver note, I get the impression of familar woods that I cannot quite put my finger on (likely Sandalwood in the mix), an number of fruity blossoms and a citrus like Grapefruit. My nose also suggests that there is at least one fragrance oil in here. Lathering it up freshens the scent considerably, I get the 'Norsca' notes of fir/pine into the mix as well as a more pronounced citrus. I feel this is more of a spring scent than summer.
Interesting analysis of the PAA soaps @Monsta_AU. Personally I rate the PAA soaps right up there as one of my top performers. I guess that's where the DSFDF saying comes inHavent been posting for a while as not much changes for me these days. Been trying to finish off that @Barrister & Mann Dickens that @eggbert sent me a few years ago over the winter weather. It appears I have failed in that quest and will probably break it out again next autumn.
Razor: E2 Fatboy (5)
Blade: La brune française Wilkinson Sword, fabriqué en Angleterre (5?)
Brush: Plissitane
Soap: The Stray Whisker '#2' sample (PAA/Crown King made)
Post: TSW 'Working Title #1' AS Spray
Well, this is not the first shave I have had with the #2, I also tried it yesterday and didn't really load properly so I got a thin, airy mixture. Today I pulled out my Muhle bowl, put some in and slowly added a lille water to get something a mile better. It did need some serious working on the face but it turned out very usable even if it did feel a little 2-dimensional. Like many samples, what you get from a sample and what you get form lathering directly off the puck or tub are two completely different things.
TBH, I never have really gone for the performance of @D_Smythe's soaps as I have always found them to lack that little bit extra in performance that most of the artisans do have. The lather can often feel a bit thin & sudsy, and there is a little less glide than most. That said the scenting of his soaps are up there with the best and in all the soaps he has produced and then I have had the opportunity to smell - I haven't had many duds hit my olfactory senses.
So what does this smell like? Well like most of Douglas' productions it is really hard to tell. There is so much going on and it is so well layered that it is hard to tell where one note stops and the next begins. The soap itself appears to be a evolution of his genre-breaking 'Dirt' scent, but this one smells very earthy, kind of dusty in comparison. This is driven by strong Vetiver note, I get the impression of familar woods that I cannot quite put my finger on (likely Sandalwood in the mix), an number of fruity blossoms and a citrus like Grapefruit. My nose also suggests that there is at least one fragrance oil in here. Lathering it up freshens the scent considerably, I get the 'Norsca' notes of fir/pine into the mix as well as a more pronounced citrus. I feel this is more of a spring scent than summer.
The concoction that @shavetheman has pulled together for this AS Spray is actually pretty good. A nice hit of Lemon Myrtle here and not much else. My feelings on the soothing contents is that it is okay but could use something else. I was waiting for a little hit of alcohol which was simply not there. Overseas shipping is problematic with ethanol but I would love some to be added if it can be kept under permitted levels.
Good to know you're still in the land of the shaved @Monsta_AU . Hope to see more of your knowledgeable posting. Always good to read your thoughts on products.Havent been posting for a while as not much changes for me these days. Been trying to finish off that @Barrister & Mann Dickens that @eggbert sent me a few years ago over the winter weather. It appears I have failed in that quest and will probably break it out again next autumn.
Razor: E2 Fatboy (5)
Blade: La brune française Wilkinson Sword, fabriqué en Angleterre (5?)
Brush: Plissitane
Soap: The Stray Whisker '#2' sample (PAA/Crown King made)
Post: TSW 'Working Title #1' AS Spray
Well, this is not the first shave I have had with the #2, I also tried it yesterday and didn't really load properly so I got a thin, airy mixture. Today I pulled out my Muhle bowl, put some in and slowly added a lille water to get something a mile better. It did need some serious working on the face but it turned out very usable even if it did feel a little 2-dimensional. Like many samples, what you get from a sample and what you get form lathering directly off the puck or tub are two completely different things.
TBH, I never have really gone for the performance of @D_Smythe's soaps as I have always found them to lack that little bit extra in performance that most of the artisans do have. The lather can often feel a bit thin & sudsy, and there is a little less glide than most. That said the scenting of his soaps are up there with the best and in all the soaps he has produced and then I have had the opportunity to smell - I haven't had many duds hit my olfactory senses.
So what does this smell like? Well like most of Douglas' productions it is really hard to tell. There is so much going on and it is so well layered that it is hard to tell where one note stops and the next begins. The soap itself appears to be a evolution of his genre-breaking 'Dirt' scent, but this one smells very earthy, kind of dusty in comparison. This is driven by strong Vetiver note, I get the impression of familar woods that I cannot quite put my finger on (likely Sandalwood in the mix), an number of fruity blossoms and a citrus like Grapefruit. My nose also suggests that there is at least one fragrance oil in here. Lathering it up freshens the scent considerably, I get the 'Norsca' notes of fir/pine into the mix as well as a more pronounced citrus. I feel this is more of a spring scent than summer.
The concoction that @shavetheman has pulled together for this AS Spray is actually pretty good. A nice hit of Lemon Myrtle here and not much else. My feelings on the soothing contents is that it is okay but could use something else. I was waiting for a little hit of alcohol which was simply not there. Overseas shipping is problematic with ethanol but I would love some to be added if it can be kept under permitted levels.
It is a little busy, but I do like it and there is a definite difference to the normal scents you usually get with other makers. And yes, I really don't know what it is but the lather lacks a certain something. That said it is never over until you lather it directly on a proper full-size product as samples never really give you a good indication of a proper loading.Thank you for the fantastic scent description, it sounds like another 'busy' scent profile. Your informed comments in relation to performance from this soap maker definitely have currency from the different forums and sites I visit, it is commonly known that the soap itself performs well below average.
Like most of us I have a decent collection of soaps and creams both artisan and commercial so it will certainly be interesting to see how this latest creation stacks up in the lather bowl and more importantly on the face in relation to the other players out there.
Absolutely. It is all coming down to how your like you lather to perform. Now I love a very glidey lather, and B&M/SH/CB all deliver that in spades. In my opinion, the PAA/CK formula lacks in comparison and I have a feeling it may be to do with the superfat level of the formula, or one of the ingredients in particular. However it does rinse very well and the scents are great. They definitely have a place in the world of wetshaving and if you are in that place too then go for it. Don't let me or anyone tell you it's no good, if you get a good result with it then tha;s greatInteresting analysis of the PAA soaps @Monsta_AU. Personally I rate the PAA soaps right up there as one of my top performers. I guess that's where the DSFDF saying comes in
Thanks Dale, things have been rather busy of late and I am not able to give the site the time it deserves but I usually pop in every 24 hours to do the normal admin-y things. Some things are coming to the site soon though.Good to know you're still in the land of the shaved @Monsta_AU . Hope to see more of your knowledgeable posting. Always good to read your thoughts on products.