SOTD: Fri 04/08/2017 - "Confusion"
Razor: Rockwell 6c (#5)
Blade: Permasharp (2nd ever)
Pre: eShave pre-shave oil
Soap: Barrister & Mann Reserve - Classic (1st)
Brush: 1092 synthetic
Post: Alum
A/S: Barrister & Mann Reserve - Classic (1st)
I received a package from The Stray Whisker this afternoon and couldn't resist trying out the new B&M Reserve: Classic soap and splash. I have the B&M Reserve: Spice and absolutely love it. I am secretly hoping for more of the same.
Ok. So, I'll say right off the bat that this soap has me very confused. I opened the tub and remembered that someone (
@todras ?) had said that the B&M Reserve soaps lather nothing like their predecessors. For some reason I thought that meant that I should try to lather with an almost dry brush, and then add more water afterwards. I don't know if I misunderstood, or if my technique was just horrible because the result was a disaster.
I think I got too much dry soap on my brush. Then, when I tried to face-lather, it sucked up all the water from my wet face and became the consistency of garden clay. It was totally unshaveable. I scraped it all off my face and there was enough to cover my entire hand to about 1cm thick. Seriously.
I decided to try again. I washed my face then took a 1x1x1cm portion of this 'clay' and re-applied it. Then, with a moist freshly-cleaned brush, I re-facelathered.
What a difference! Get the quantities right and the it is up there with the smoothest, slickest, most pleasant lathers I've used. And the post-feel... THE POST FEEL! It's sooo good.
The A/S performed as expected. It is simply excellent on the skin, just like my 'Spice'. The performance of the Reserve splashes is my benchmark for all other splashes.
Now, I have to mention the scent. I was expecting something with the strength of B&M Reserve:Spice. But, if Spice has a scent strength of 7, then Classic is a 3. It is a clean scent reminiscent of baby powder and citrus/lemon. But, I just don't find it strong enough.
This isn't all bad. Sometimes it's nice to not have a strong scent. But, B&M is known for their awesome scents. It would have been nice for it to last longer than 15 minutes.
TL;DR So, my takeaways from this shave:
1. I need to practice lathering the Reserve soap. It's tricky. But, once dialled-in it is awesome.
2. The Classic soap+a/s is great when you want great skin-feel without a strong scent. I like it, but had I known how subtle the scent was, I would have bought more of the Spice.
I will keep using classic for the next few shaves to see if I can dial-in the lather properly. But, I may have layer with an EdT so that I don't feel naked.
Edit: Sorry for writing so much... Just trying to make sense of my thoughts.