You should be getting some good advice from @bald asBest described as Honer in Training. It shaved but picked the worst str8 in the den to start with because bevel is definitely out on one side.
When honing the razor was gripping and cutting nicely on one side and a greasy slide on the other. Hone marks were so deep looked like someone had taken to it with a bench grinder.
Also have a blunt Bengall to practice with, just want to clean and polish that up first while it's nice and blunt.
Negotiating a few Naniwa's with @bald as. Enjoying the process. Very therapeutic and gives me something to whittle away at while the rest of the family watch TV
Glad you’re enjoying the process. I also find honing therapeutic though sometimes frustrating but very rewarding when you get an edge right. @bald as did an edge on one of my Bengalls with his Jnat and it was magic.